MindFrame

Compare · Brain-training games

MindFrame vs Lumosity

Lumosity is a collection of short games that exercise processing speed, memory and attention. MindFrame trains metacognition: whether your confidence matches your accuracy, and how well you reason. This page says what each does, where they differ, and what neither has evidence for.

What Lumosity does well

  • An engaging, game-like experience that makes a daily habit easy to keep
  • Practice for processing speed and basic attention tasks
  • A large library of games
  • Easy to start: little to learn before your first game

Where MindFrame differs

What gets trained

Lumosity games ask you to respond quickly and accurately. MindFrame asks you to answer, say how sure you are, and then compares the two. The thing being practised is the match between confidence and accuracy (calibration), plus the quality of your written reasoning.

What the research on brain games found

A 2016 review of brain-training studies (Simons et al.) found improvement on the trained tasks but little evidence of real-world transfer to everyday performance.

What the research on metacognitive instruction found

A 2018 meta-analysis of 67 school studies (de Boer, Donker & van der Werf) found metacognitive strategy instruction improved academic performance by about g = 0.63 — a typical trained student scored above roughly 73% of untrained peers. Those were school studies of taught strategies, not users of an app.

Side by side

Primary training focus

LumosityProcessing speed, memory, attention

MindFrameMetacognition: how you monitor and regulate your own thinking

Evidence base

LumosityReviewed by Simons et al. (2016): improvement on trained tasks, little evidence of wider benefit

MindFrameBuilt on published metacognition research (de Boer et al. 2018 and others); MindFrame's own outcomes are not yet measured

Reasoning scoring

LumosityNot a focus

MindFrameWritten reasoning is scored by rules first and by AI when rules cannot decide

Calibration measurement

LumosityNot a focus

MindFrameBrier score and calibration error for every session

AI coaching

LumosityNot a focus

MindFrameFeedback on your reasoning after a challenge, with a daily allowance

Daily habit

LumosityStrong: polished, game-like

MindFrameStructured challenges with progress tracking

What neither has evidence for

  • That practice inside either product makes your decisions better outside it. MindFrame has not run an outcome study.
  • That either product raises intelligence or protects mental health.
  • That the school research on metacognitive instruction carries over to a self-directed app. MindFrame has not yet run a controlled study, so we do not claim it produces the effect sizes reported in the research. We will publish our own numbers, including weak ones, once we have them.

The full list of what MindFrame has not proven is on trust; the research it builds on is on science.

Which to choose

Choose Lumosity if

  • You want a fun, game-like experience
  • Your goal is speed or reaction time specifically
  • You want the lowest possible barrier to starting

Choose MindFrame if

  • You want to see whether your confidence matches your accuracy
  • You want your written reasoning scored, not only your answers
  • You are comfortable with a product that says what it has not yet proven

All 19 training modes are free. Try one question without an account, or start a session.

References

Other comparisons