MindFrame

Compare · Processing-speed training

MindFrame vs BrainHQ

BrainHQ, from Posit Science, is a set of exercises for processing speed and attention. Much of its published research is with older adults. MindFrame trains metacognition: whether your confidence matches your accuracy, and how well you reason. This page says what each does, where they differ, and what neither has evidence for.

What BrainHQ does well

  • A stated research focus on speed-of-processing exercises, aimed mainly at older adults
  • A clear target: processing speed and visual attention

Where MindFrame differs

BrainHQ trains speed and attention

Processing speed and attention are about how quickly and cleanly you take information in. BrainHQ's exercises are built around those, and its research is strongest where processing speed declines most measurably, in later life.

MindFrame trains judgment about your own answers

Metacognition sits above raw processing: whether your confidence matches your knowledge, whether you catch your own errors, whether you update when the evidence changes. Faster processing does not by itself make confidence more accurate, and MindFrame does not train speed.

Research each one builds on

A 2018 meta-analysis of 67 school studies (de Boer, Donker & van der Werf) found metacognitive strategy instruction improved academic performance by about g = 0.63 — a typical trained student scored above roughly 73% of untrained peers. In clinical trials reviewed by Normann & Morina (2021), metacognitive therapy outperformed Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) by about g = 0.69. This is therapy research; it supports the principle, not a training app. Neither finding is a measured MindFrame result.

Using both

The two aim at different things and do not overlap much. If your concern is processing speed in later life, BrainHQ is the one that targets it. MindFrame adds practice in judging how far to trust your own answers.

Side by side

Primary training target

BrainHQProcessing speed and attention

MindFrameCalibration, reasoning quality and updating

Evidence

BrainHQPublishes its own research list; we have not reviewed it

MindFrameBuilt on published metacognition research (de Boer et al. 2018 and others); MindFrame's own outcomes are not yet measured

Age group studied

BrainHQMostly older adults

MindFrameNo age-group outcome data yet

Calibration training

BrainHQNot a focus

MindFrameBrier score and calibration error for every session

Reasoning scoring

BrainHQSpeed and accuracy

MindFrameWritten reasoning is scored, not only the answer

Cognitive bias practice

BrainHQNot a focus

MindFrameModes built around recognising specific biases

What neither has evidence for

  • That practice inside either product makes your decisions better outside it. MindFrame has not run an outcome study.
  • That either product raises intelligence or protects mental health.
  • That MindFrame helps any particular age group. MindFrame has not yet run a controlled study, so we do not claim it produces the effect sizes reported in the research. We will publish our own numbers, including weak ones, once we have them.

The full list of what MindFrame has not proven is on trust; the research it builds on is on science.

Which to choose

Choose BrainHQ if

  • You are focused on processing speed and attention, especially in later life
  • You want exercises with a published trial record for that goal
  • Your goal is faster, more accurate perception

Choose MindFrame if

  • Your goal is judgment rather than speed
  • You want calibration: an accurate sense of what you do and do not know
  • You want your reasoning scored and your bias patterns tracked over time

All 19 training modes are free. Try one question without an account, or start a session.

References

Other comparisons